IslamQA.org Logo

Audio: Is a woman riding alone with a male taxi driver considered to be in unlawful seclusion (

Answered according to Shafi'i Fiqh by Qibla.com

Answered by Shaykh Amjad Rasheed

Is a woman’s riding alone in a taxi driven by a man considered to be khalwa (impermissible seclusion)? What about when she needs to use a taxi alone for her daily needs and her husband doesn’t come back home until late?

Answer:
In the Name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful

Audio: Is a woman riding alone with a male taxi driver considered to be in unlawful seclusion (khalwa) http://www.sunnipath.com/resources/Questions/qa00003683.aspx 

Recorded translation by Faraz Rabbani
Text translation by Shazia Ahmad

The khalwa that is haram is for a man and a woman not immediately related to be together in a place where the unlawful could happen. As for being alone in other than such a place, like where people pass by regularly, it is not seclusion, nor is it haram as long as she is wearing the hijab according to the shari`ah. Likewise, two women with one man and or several men is not khalwa. As for two men being along with one woman, it is khalwa in our school, but is not according certain scholars such as the Malikis school and in that is ease.

As for riding in a taxi, it is not considered to be khalwa in and of itself, but there is some detail regarding it. So one would say, that if the taxi is going along frequented routes and there is nothing that would prevent passer-bys by seeing inside the taxi, it is not khalwa, otherwise, if it is going along a route where there aren’t many passer-bys or in a place where there are, but there is something blocking people from seeing into the car [f. such as tinted windows] such that enables something haram to happen in the taxi, it is khalwa, unless there is someone else in the taxi with her such as a woman, or a mahram man, like her husband or even a child that is close to puberty, then it is not haram.

In our times, there are many forms of public transportation in which many women and men travel where there is no khalwa, so let her choose to use this transport instead of a taxi alone, for this could lead to impermissible khalwa or something dangerous and unbecoming. Also, one should know that the reason for such types of seclusion is to protect the woman’s dignity itself and to avoid anything unbecoming from happening, and also to protect righteous and dignified behaviour in society. It has been related in a hadith, “Whenever a man and woman gather alone, Shaytan is third amongst them”. And this is not denied except by someone who arrogant.

– Amjad Rasheed

 

السؤال: هل ركوب المرأة في التكسي وحدها خلوة ؟ كيف لو احتاجت إليه لمصالحها اليومية ، وزوجُها لا يرجع من العمل إلا متأخّراً ؟ الجواب : الخلوة المحرمة هي اجتماعُ رجل وامرأة أجنبيين في مكان يمكن وقوع الفاحشة فيه، أما اجتماعُهما في غير ذلك المكان بأن يكون المكانُ مطروقاً ( يتعاقب عليه الناس ) فليس بخلوة ولا يحرم طالما التزمت المرأة الحجاب الشرعي ، وكذلك اجتماع امرأتين مع رجل أو رجال ليس بخلوة ، أما اجتماعُ رجلين بامرأة فهو خلوة في مذهبنا ، وليس بخلوة عند بعض العلماء كالمالكية وفيه سعة . وركوبُ المرأة التكسي ليس خلوة بحد ذاته ، بل يفصل فيه فيقال : إن كان السيرُ في التكسي في مكان مطروق وليس هناك ما يمنع نظر المارة إلى ما في داخل السيارة فليس بخلوة، وإلا فإن كان السيرُ في مكان غير مطروق أو في مطروق لكن هناك ما يمنع نظر المارة إلى ما في السيارة بحيث يمكن وقوع الفاحشة كان خلوة محرمة إلا إن كان مع المرأة امرأة غيرها أو محرم كزوج أو ولد ولو مراهقاً فلا يحرم حينئذ ، وقد انتشرت اليوم وسائط النقل المشتركة التي يجتمع فيها الرجال والنساء بحيث لا تكون خلوة فلتختار المرأة الركوب فيها على الركوب في التكسي وحدها مما قد يعرضها للخلوة المحرمة ، ولتعلم المرأة أن تحرم الخلوة على الوجه المذكور ما هو إلا حفاظاً عليها خاصة من تعرضها لما يؤذيها في عرضها ، وحفاظا على فضيلة المجتمع عامة ، وفي الحديث :” ما اجتمع رجل بامرأة إلا كان الشيطان ثالثهما “. وهذا لا ينكره إلا مكابر .

This answer was indexed from Qibla.com, which used to have a repository of Islamic Q&A answered by various scholars. The website is no longer in existence. It has now been transformed into a learning portal with paid Islamic course offering under the brand of Kiflayn.

Find more answers indexed from: Qibla.com
Read more answers with similar topics:
Subscribe to IslamQA Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to IslamQA Weekly Newsletter

You will receive 5 Q&A in your inbox every week



We have sent a confirmation to you. Please check the and confirm your subscription. Thank you!