Why don’t Hanafis combine prayers, when there are authentic hadiths about it?
In the Name of Allah the Inspirer of truth.
This issue is a major one between the fiqhi schools. The Hanafis have judged all the narrations on this issue to be based on the method of “apparent combining” (Jam’ al-Suri) not “real combining” (jam’ al-Haqiqi). What this means is that since we are told to make every prayer on time, and there are hadiths of Ibn Mas’ud which clarify that the Prophet Sallallahu alayhi wassalam never combined the prayers together (by taking a prayer out of its time) except in ‘Arafa and Muzdalifa during the pilgrimage.
The following, which is an excerpt the from the Fiqh al-Imam (third edition) currently under publication, may be useful in understanding the hadiths on this issue:
From the Chapter on “Combing Two Prayers”
3. ‘Abdullah ibn Mas’ud relates:
I never observed the Messenger of Allah perform any prayer out of its time except at Muzdalifa. He combined Maghrib and ‘Isha at Muzdalifa (Sahih al-Bukhari 1:227, Sahih Muslim 1:417, Sharh Ma’ani ‘l-athar 1:164).
4. Another narration of Ibn Mas’ud states:
The Messenger of Allah combined two prayers whilst on a journey. He would combine Maghrib and ‘Isha by delaying Maghrib until just before its expiry time, and performing ‘Isha immediately as its time entered (Musannaf Ibn Abi Shayba 2:458).
5. ‘A’isha narrates:
The Messenger of Allah, whilst on a journey, would delay Zuhr and perform ‘Asr early and would delay Maghrib and perform ‘Isha early (i.e. perform each prayer in its own time) (Sharh Ma’ani ‘l-athar 1:164, Musannaf Ibn Abi Shayba 2:457).
6. Ibn ‘Abbas t narrates:
I performed eight rak’ats together (four of Zuhr and four of ‘Asr) and seven rak’ats together (three of Maghrib and four of ‘Isha) with the Messenger of Allah. (One of the narrators says,) “I asked Abu ‘l-Sha’tha’, ‘I assume he delayed Zuhr (to the end of its time) and performed ‘Asr as soon as it entered, and delayed Maghrib (likewise) and performed ‘Isha early.’ He replied, ‘I also think the same’” (Sahih Muslim 1:246, Musannaf Ibn Abi Shayba 2: 456).
This hadith of Sahih Muslim is very clear about the exact description of combining two prayers. The method described by the narrator is jam’ al-suri.
7. Imam Abu Dawud has transmitted the following:
The muezzin of ‘Abdullah ibn ‘Umar informed him it was time for prayer. Ibn ‘Umar instructed him to continue on the journey. When the red of sunset (shafq ahmar) had nearly disappeared, he got of from his mount and performed Maghrib, and then he waited until the red had completely disappeared and performed Isha. He then said, “Whenever the Messenger of Allah e was in a hurry for some reason, he would do just as I have done” (Sunan Abi Dawud 1:178).
As we can see, the method of combining mentioned in the above hadiths is none other than that of jam’ al-suri. It is an agreed upon method which nobody has any argument with. How can there be an objection to two prayers being performed together in a way that does not cause them to be performed either before their stipulated time or after it? Undoubtedly, this is the safest method of combining two prayers, and would be the most suitable way to explain the hadiths on combining.
It is also common knowledge that the Fajr prayer should not to be performed before its time or intentionally delayed beyond it. Similarly, other prayers should not be performed out of their stipulated times either, especially not while considering it to be sunna. This indicates that the sunna method of combining two prayers is jam’ al-suri, as has also been substantiated through the Qur’an and hadiths. This is the Hanafi opinion in this issue.
If it was permissible to practice jam’ al-haqiqi in the event of travel or illness, etc., then why is it confined to some prayers only? Why is it not permissible to perform all the prayers of the day together in the morning before departing on a journey? The reason for this is quite simple. The practice of combining mentioned in the hadiths is not to be taken as jam al-haqiqi, but as jam al-suri wherein each prayer remains in its own time, but are performed one after another.
And Allah knows best.
Mufti Abdurrahman ibn Yusuf