My question is whether this HAJ is valid? Why not we make a tasreeh? As HAJ is compulsory on those who can bear the expenses, if we cannot make official permission (TASREEH), is Haj compulsory (FARZ) on us?
Few people giving the reason that your HAJ is valid, but you have disobeyed the Govt which is sin. So how can I perform HAJ making sin? I am doing HAJ same like thieves.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
(Fatwa: 1452/1452/M=12/1434)
Hajj means to perform particular rituals, so if anyone goes to Makkah in hajj days and performs those rituals, then his hajj will be valid. But going to perform hajj without government permission is putting yourself in danger which should be avoided. You should perform hajj with official permission.
Allah knows Best!
Darul Ifta,
Darul Uloom Deoband
