Answered by Shaykh Amjad Rasheed
Translated by Ustadha Shazia Ahmad
Based on the fact that the relied upon position in our school is that the farewell circumambulation is not a part of the hajj and that it is obligatory to perform for whoever wants to leave Mecca, even for a short distance and even if he was not in ihram for hajj or umra, does one have to slaughter if one omits it?
Yes, a person who leaves the farewell circumambulation must slaughter according to the relied upon position. It is not a part of hajj and it is obligatory on even a person who is not in ihram. So upon this position, slaughter is necessary as our imams have said.
It is mentioned in the Tuhfa that this ruling applies to him because although he is not in ihram, he is in the appearance of someone who is. […]