I was just wondering what the ruling in Islam is on back-biting, with resources from the Bukhari and Muslim Hadiths… I was also wondering whether it is permissible for muslims to say “Astaghfirullah” upon seeing another fellow muslim brother or sister doing an unlawful act (in Islam)… or are we to keep silent and say nothing?… Please if you could, give the resources from the Bukhari or Muslim hadiths?!
JazakAllah Khair
| Answer | |
|
| Public Notes |
Stopping others from doing sins is a Muslim’s duty (if within their power). However, some tact must be used in their approach and one should proceed with leniency and not be harsh in their manner nor embarrass them as this may have a counter-effect and build resentment. I believe it was the Late Moulana Yusuf Ludhyanwi (shaheed) who attributed the ineffectiveness of communication on the absence of one of three factors; correct intention, accurate message and proper manner of conveyance. Insha’Allah if all three are present the advice will have some effect. |
|---|
