Its wrong to recite Sana in 3rd rakat of witar
My freind told me a mas’ala that when offering 3 witar is it nessesary to read sa’na in 3rd rakat ? Is it true ?
Thana should not be recited in the third rakaat. Not only is it not necessary, but to recite it is wrong. The third rakaat is not a rakaat by its self, but rather it the third of three.
Original Source Link (from Way Back Machine archive)
Dear respected Ulama – e – Kiraam, Assalamu Alaikum, Someone once asked me: ‘If destiny lies in Allah’s hands, then why will people who haven’t even been shown the light of Islam get punished?’ This person gave an example of what they meant. They said: A child is born into a non-muslim family. This family live in a country where there are no other religions known except for.. let’s just say Christianity. So this child is brought up as a Christian. They have absolutely any knowldege of any other religion. So this person being a Christian or whatever religion.. they will end up going to Jahannam because they did not accept islam. But this person didnt in his life ever hear about it. But again… this person will be put into hell even though it wasnt his fault that he lived in a place where only his religion was known. It would be different if a Muslim had come to the place and called them to islam but that didnt happen for them. So he will be punished? What i know of this is that many Ulama e Kiraam have told us to not even go near this subject. But if anyone does have an answer, I would greatly appreciate it if the answer be put forward. May Allah Ta’ala reward you all. Ameen. Wassalam.