1. can a girl consider two marriage proposals at the same time? 2. I proposed to a girl not knowing that she was proposed by another brother. despite this, she told me she wanted to get to know me better (so she did not accept or reject my proposal outright). Later i found out she was talking this other brother about marriage (even after I proposed). Should she have just given me an answer and moved on? Or is it ok for her to float my proposal while she discusses with others nikah opportunities? 3. I’m not sure if i remember correctly, but there was a hadith that said that a muslim brother should not propose to a girl if he knows that someone else propose to her. so have i sinned? I did istikhara also. Please help w/ this urgent matter. Jazakallah.
Any kind of premarital relationship between the boy and girl is Haraam. The
concept of ‘getting to know one another’ is the influence of the Kuffaar
customs and is largely the cause of the escalating divorce rate among the
Muslim Ummah, for Nikahs based on Haraam (unlawful practices) are devoid of
Divine blessings which are constant source of love and affection between the
partners. Therefore, great care should be taken to act upon the dictates of
the Qur’aan and Sunnah wherein lies only good for the obedient servants of a
Bountiful Allah.
Although a girl may consider as many proposals as received, this is no
excuse for frivolous and irresponsible behaviour, thus causing ill feelings
and rivalry among suitors. Marriage to such a female should be very
carefully considered and divine guidance be sought on the matter. The
prohibition in the Hadith referred by you applies only when one advances his
proposal despite being aware that his brother’s proposal has not, as yet,
been rejected or is still being considered by the proposed.
and Allah Ta’ala Knows Best
Mufti Ebrahim Desai
FATWA DEPT.