difference of opinion

Browse 972 answers in this category

You are on page 26

What is the status of the hadīth “Seek knowledge even as far as China”?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Confusion about making du`a before reading sunnah.

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Sajdah Tilawah in Tarawih

Shaykh Arshad Ali, Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Reference of Hadith on two armies fighting each other

Shaykh Ebrahim Desai, Shaykh Nabeel ValliRead

Divorce in state of anger

Shaykh Arshad Ali, Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

  I am in lot of pain right now. I was married in 2004 on my choice with my cousin but my mother has not accepted her from the very first day. My mother maintained a very strict behaviour with her while I tried to balance the situation all the time. My wife compromised on lot of things such as not going to her siblings marriages and not going to see her ill father. Now, after 10 years of her marriage with me and due to continuous stress she got, she started replying in high tone to my mother. Sir, they regularly fought and i was trying to cool down the situation all the time but my mother had recently maintained a stance that she is not willing to stay in home with me if my wife stays here. My mother said that if i will keep my wife here then she will leave the home. Sir, in these 10 years i tried my level best to balance the relation but conditions got worst. My wife is not a bad woman, she use to take care of my mother once she was ill but i do not know what had gone wrong with my mother as she maintained such arogant behaviour with my wife. Sir, the issue is this that my father expired when i was probably 2 years old and i have no brother or sister. My mother brought me up and she is very possessive about me. Sir, on 22nd June 2014, my wife and mother had extreme fight and i was trying to stop them. During the fight my mother provoked me a lot. The limit was reached in anger where I was about to kill them all (including children) as I grabbed them from their throats, even I searched for a knife to kill them. Sir, because of getting continous stress, being out of control in extreme anger and without having prior intention of divorce i said to my wife that, “Mainy tumhain or tum kou (1 out of these words) talak di, Mainy tumhain or tum kou (1 out of these words) talak di, Mainy tumhain or tum kou (1 out of these words) talak di” in one go and probably within 10-15 seconds. Sir, my wife heard these words and she was having her periods since 17th June 2014 and it was her 6th day (22nd June 2014) of periods, she was not clean as she did not take the bath, she takes bath on 7th day of periods. I was not knowing that she is having periods as she was hospitalized probably on 20th June 2014 as she took few pills inorder to kill herself after getting disheart from my mother’s behaviour who tourchered her mentally by saying that my wife is misbehaving with her. Sir, my wife did not tell me as well regarding her periods. Sir, I was in extreme anger because of that fight and due to continuous stress been given to me by the fight i did this act in extreme anger. I had no prior intention to divorce my wife during the fight. My mother said it many times that i have done a big mistake by marrying my wife and she even said that I should get second marriage. All the situation arised because my wife became frustrated and took tablets inorder to kill herself and she was admitted in hospital. I brought her to home on 22nd June 2014 and my mother said that she will leave the home if i keep my wife here. They both had a fight like i cannot explain, I tried to stop them from fighting and in this extreme tense and anger situation i did that act. Sir, please guide and let me know answer of following questions :-  Question : 1) Was the divorce I gave is valid for 3 times or will it be counted as 1 talak ? Question : 2) Was the divorce valid because my wife was also having periods (6th day) and I was not knowing about her periods ? Question : 3) Was the divorce I gave is valid because it was given in such an extreme condition of anger where I nearly lost my senses and was even ready to kill my family with my own hands which a nomral person in senses cannot think of doing ? Question : 4) Do i have a chance of continuing my marriage again with the type of talak I gave or my marriage is over with my wife ? Sir, I have 2 sons and their life will be ruined. Sir, please help me out in this desperate situation as i feel like killing myself, thanks and regards.

Shaykh Arshad Ali, Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Is Zakat calculated on debts that were written off?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Is Zakat due on shares in a housing scheme, RSP’s, RRSP’s, and stocks?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

“Eight or Twenty?” The Truth In The Light of Ahadeeth

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

How do I pay Zakat on my 401(k) plan?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Is the narration about a person in the qabr returning salām to the living true?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Why can’t a husband bathe (i.e. give ghusl to) his deceased wife?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Was the flood in the time of Nuh (A.S) a global event or a regional event?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Hanafi Husband and Ahle hadeeth wife

Shaykh Arshad Ali, Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

What are the references in Hadith for these stories?

Shaykh Ebrahim Desai, Shaykh Nabeel ValliRead

Does one leave the folds of Islam simply by disposing the Names of Allah into a trash bin?

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Clarification and Laws of Vaginal Discharge

Shaykh Ebrahim DesaiRead

Is eating prawns haalal or makroo

Askimam.orgRead

Solar heated water

Shaykh Ismail MoosaRead

Microphone in Salah

Shaykh Ismail MoosaRead